Menu

The 15 Best Key Lime Pies in Houston

Seeking a slice of sweet, tart, mouthwatering key lime pie in Houston? You've landed on the perfect page. This bustling city offers a variety of establishments whipping up this delicious dessert staple.

Get ready to dive into the vivid world of Key Lime Pie in Houston. From the big-name bakeries to the hidden local gems, Houston houses a galaxy of spots brimming with tantalising takes on the classic Key Lime Pie. Our comprehensive list is about to lead you to your next favourite dessert destination.

With a spectrum of tastes and textures to try, upscaled, down-home, fancy, or frugal, Houston has it all. Dig into our selection of the Best Key Lime Pies in Houston and let your taste buds lead the way.

How we rank this list

We chose key lime pies in Houston with a proven record among their customers and ranked them with the specialists first. The list is reviewed regularly so it stays current.

A few businesses pay to stand out, always after passing our editorial review and with a label that says so.

Top 3All listingsMapHow to decide

All 15 local options compared

2 Phat Bastard Pies, Houston#1
Strengths
  • The lamb curry filling is very flavorful with a spicy kick to it.

  • The quality of the dough is flaky and baked fresh.

  • The chicken jalapeño pie is very spicy but tasty.

  • The steak and mushroom pie feels like a British classic.

2 Phat Bastard Pies

4.963 reviews
606 Dennis St, Houston, TX 77006, United States

2 Phat Bastard Pies is a unique pie shop in Houston that offers a fusion of British, Indian, and African flavors in a delightful pie form. Customers rave about the delicious and flavorful pies, from the Lamb Curry Pie to the Chicken & Mushroom Pie. The pies are known for their flaky crusts and generous fillings, with options like pepper steak, beef curry, chicken jalapeño, and more. The owners, who are originally from Zimbabwe, also offer halal meat options for their pies.

Customers not only appreciate the delicious pies but also the excellent service provided by the staff. Whether it's for in-store pick-up, delivery, or dine-in, 2 Phat Bastard Pies ensures that customers have a satisfying experience. With a ranking of 4.9 based on 63 reviews, it's clear that this pie shop has won the hearts of many in Houston. If you're looking for a unique pie experience that tantalizes your taste buds with international flavors, 2 Phat Bastard Pies is the place to be!

Lucy Pearls, Houston#2
Strengths
  • The atomic cake is a standout favorite, offering a unique combination of flavors in a single slice.

  • The carrot cake has been highly praised for its authentic flavor and perfect cream cheese frosting.

  • The Brooklyn blackout cake has received glowing reviews for its amazing taste, presentation, and freshness.

  • The Lemon Blueberry Cupcakes have been a huge hit at weddings, wowing guests with their deliciousness and professional service.

Lucy Pearls

4.7169 reviews
401 Franklin St Suite 1235, Houston, TX 77201, United States

Lucy Pearls is a renowned Bakery located in Houston that has captured the hearts of many dessert aficionados. The bakery offers a delightful array of cakes, pies, cupcakes, and more that have left customers raving about their exceptional quality and taste.

With a ranking of 4.7 and a wide range of services such as delivery, in-store pick-up, and dine-in options, Lucy Pearls continues to be a top choice for those seeking delectable desserts in Houston.

Proud Pie, Houston#3
Strengths
  • The pies at Proud Pie are described as fantastic, with a wide variety of flavors and options to choose from. Each pie is crafted with care and attention to detail, resulting in a perfect balance of flavors and textures.

  • Customers enjoy the flaky crusts, deliciously rich fillings, and the overall delightful experience of indulging in a slice of pie at Proud Pie.

  • Many reviewers highlight the friendly and knowledgeable staff, who are always ready to help customers navigate through the many delicious looking selections.

Proud Pie

4.61,372 reviews
3522 S Mason Rd, Katy, TX 77450, United States

Proud Pie is a charming pie shop located in Katy, TX, offering a delightful selection of pies that have captured the hearts of many customers. With a ranking of 4.6, this hidden gem has garnered 1372 reviews that praise its exceptional pies and cozy ambiance.

Whether you're a fan of classic fruit pies or adventurous flavors, Proud Pie is the perfect spot to savor a slice of pie with friends or family. Visit their website to explore their service options such as delivery and in-store pick-up, and don't miss out on trying their mouth-watering pies that have left customers raving about their unforgettable pie experience.

Flying Saucer Pie Company, Houston#4
Strengths
  • Friendly service and affordable prices

  • Wide variety of pie flavors available by the slice

  • Cherry and lemon pies are bursting with flavor

  • High quality pies make the wait worth it

Flying Saucer Pie Company

4.61,346 reviews
436 W Crosstimbers St, Houston, TX 77018, United States

Flying Saucer Pie Company is a beloved pie shop in Houston that offers a wide variety of delicious pies. Customers rave about the friendly service and the affordable prices. The option to buy pies by the slice allows patrons to enjoy a variety of flavors without committing to a whole pie. The cherry and lemon pies are particularly popular for their bursting flavor and perfect balance between sweet and tart. While the service may be a bit slow at times, the high quality of the pies makes it worth the wait. This cozy pie shop also offers in-store pick-up and in-store shopping for added convenience. If you're a pie lover, don't miss out on this delightful experience!

Pie Factory, Houston#5
Strengths
  • I wanted a mincemeat pie for a gift and randomly discovered the Pie Factory not far from where I live. Deep dish, very good flavors, and wonderful crust. Just perfection.

  • We had a Veterans Day celebration and they made us a full sheet cake with amazing buttercream frosting. The taste was out of this world!

  • Better than flying saucer pies! Made to order a Boston creme and strawberry rhubarb, and they were excellent!

  • The key lime pie is amazing! My entire family loved it!

Pie Factory

4.828 reviews
5611 Bellaire Blvd suite 128, Houston, TX 77081, United States

Pie Factory is a delightful pie shop located in Houston, TX. They offer a variety of services including in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, takeaway, and quick visits for those in a rush. Customers rave about their tasty pies and cakes, praising the deep dish flavors and wonderful crust.

Texas Pie Guy, Houston#6
Strengths
  • This bakery offers some of the best pies customers have ever tasted.

  • The pecan pie is highlighted for its amazing flavor and perfect balance of sweetness.

  • Customers praise the smoked pecan pie for its unique and elevated taste.

  • The variety of flavors and the quality of the pies have left customers wanting more.

Texas Pie Guy

4.818 reviews
2520 Airline Dr, Houston, TX 77009, United States

Texas Pie Guy is a renowned pop-up bakery in Houston, TX that has captured the hearts and taste buds of many customers with its delicious pies. The bakery offers a range of services including takeaway options and wheelchair-accessible facilities. For payment convenience, they accept credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

With a stellar rating of 4.8 stars, Texas Pie Guy has received glowing reviews from satisfied customers. Some key points from the reviews include:

With a focus on quality, flavor, and customer satisfaction, Texas Pie Guy continues to impress pie lovers with their delectable creations. Visit their website for more information on their upcoming pop-up locations and treat yourself to a slice of pie heaven.

Ms. Myrtle's Bakery Shoppe, Houston#7
Strengths
  • This place does not disappoint. The chocolate chip cookies were perfect and customer service was fantastic.

  • The coconut cake with glaze is incredible. The customer always happy to support a Black-owned business.

  • Hidden little gem with the best mini bundt cakes in the area. Every flavor is great with delicious icing and moist cake.

  • Ms. Myrtle's Bakery Shoppe made a delicious wedding cake at a great price. Highly recommended.

Ms. Myrtle's Bakery Shoppe

4.3171 reviews
2020 Emancipation Ave, Houston, TX 77003, United States

Ms. Myrtle's Bakery Shoppe is a charming Bakery located in Houston that offers a variety of delicious treats. Customers can enjoy services like Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, and Takeaway. The bakery is Wheelchair-accessible, making it convenient for all visitors. For those looking to relax or work, Wi-Fi is available. The welcoming atmosphere includes a friendly LGBTQ+ crowd. Ms. Myrtle's Bakery Shoppe is known for its flavorful mini bundt cakes, coconut cake, pies, and cookie cake sandwiches. Customers have praised the bakery for its tasty treats and affordable prices. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Three Brothers Bakery, Houston#8
Strengths
  • Customers praise the welcoming staff and high-quality treats.

  • Many enjoy the wide variety of pastries and bread available.

  • Some customers mentioned the fair pricing and convenient location.

Three Brothers Bakery

4.2513 reviews
4036 S Braeswood Blvd, Houston, TX 77025, United States

Three Brothers Bakery is a charming bakery located in Houston, TX. They offer a wide variety of freshly baked goods, from cherry pies to challah bread and pastries. The friendly staff ensures every customer has a pleasant experience, making it a favorite spot for both regulars and first-time visitors.

With a ranking of 4.2 out of 5, it's no surprise that customers keep coming back to Three Brothers Bakery for their sweet cravings. Whether you're looking for a delicious treat or planning a special occasion, this family-owned bakery comes highly recommended.

Flo Paris, Houston#9
Strengths
  • A quiet bakery cafe with plenty of open tables.

  • Delicious sweets and a great place to study during downtime.

  • Plenty of seating, good mix of pastries and breakfast items.

  • Elegant atmosphere, amazing desserts, and friendly service.

Flo Paris

4.2364 reviews
5757 Westheimer Rd #105, Houston, TX 77057, United States

Flo Paris is a charming Patisserie located in Houston, offering a variety of sweet treats and savory options. Customers have praised the Great desserts they serve and the LGBTQ+ friendly environment. Here are some key highlights from the reviews:

The bakery offers Service options like Delivery and In-store pick-up, as well as Dining options for Breakfast and Dessert. With high praises for their desserts and welcoming atmosphere, Flo Paris is a must-visit spot for anyone with a sweet tooth.

House of Pies, Houston#10
Strengths
  • If you're in the mood for an old-school, greasy spoon diner experience, House of Pies is the place to be. The food is consistent and the staff are friendly and attentive.

  • House of Pies is not just about desserts, their grilled chicken meal is a hidden gem on the menu that showcases culinary excellence.

  • Customers appreciate the affordable prices, delicious food, and exceptional service at this diner, making it a must-visit for breakfast or any meal.

House of Pies

4.45,903 reviews
3112 Kirby Dr, Houston, TX 77098, United States

House of Pies is a beloved American restaurant in Houston that offers a range of dining options and amenities to cater to its diverse clientele. Known for its fast service, great coffee, and delicious dessert, this restaurant is a go-to spot for locals and tourists alike. Customers rave about the cozy and casual atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for a relaxing meal.

Whether you're stopping by for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, House of Pies has something for everyone. With a range of dining options and service options like delivery and takeaway, this restaurant provides a delightful dining experience for all.

House of Pies, Houston#11
Strengths
  • Customers praise the excellent food and service, making it a frequent visit for those craving pies.

  • The menu redesign and added extras have enhanced the dining experience, with favorites like grilled cheese and various pies standing out.

  • House of Pies is deemed a classic spot with good food, perfect for a quick date or a late-night snack.

House of Pies

4.45,215 reviews
6142 Westheimer Rd, Houston, TX 77057, United States

House of Pies is renowned for its classic American cuisine and delectable desserts. They offer a variety of services like Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. Customers rave about the fast service and the indulgent desserts, especially the pies. Some key highlights of the business include Great coffee and Great dessert. The atmosphere is described as Casual and Cosy, making it a favorite spot for University students and Groups.

Epicure Café, Houston#12
Strengths
  • We came here on a Sunday afternoon to have lunch with family. The ambience was exactly what we were looking for, and everything we ate tasted very good.

  • Tucked away in River Oaks is this cute little Cafe that makes you feel like you have taken a vacation far away. Anything you choose is made with love and delicious!

  • This cafe is a hidden gem nestled in the walkable River Oaks area. The food is homemade and delicious, and the ambiance is bustling and trendy.

  • Breakfast food was delicious, unfortunately, the princess cake wasn’t as good as expected. The service was great and fast overall.

Epicure Café

4.4426 reviews
2005 W Gray St, Houston, TX 77019, United States

Epicure Café is a charming spot in Houston that offers a variety of services to its customers. From great coffee to delicious desserts, this café is popular for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Customers praise the fast service and great tea selection. The café's cosy atmosphere and trendy vibe make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Three Brothers Bakery, Houston#13
Strengths
  • Clean, relaxing atmosphere with friendly and knowledgeable staff.

  • Delicious cakes and desserts, with unique options like the award-winning key lime pie.

  • Beautifully decorated cakes for special occasions, with careful attention to detail.

  • Helpful and considerate service, making every visit a pleasant experience.

Three Brothers Bakery

4.1419 reviews
4606 Washington Ave, Houston, TX 77007, United States

Three Brothers Bakery is a beloved establishment in Houston that offers a wide range of delightful baked goods. Customers can enjoy the convenience of in-store pick-up and takeaway options, making it easy to satisfy their sweet cravings. While same-day delivery may not be available, the welcoming and accessible atmosphere of the bakery more than makes up for it.

With a solid 4.1-star rating, it's no surprise that customers rave about their experiences at Three Brothers Bakery. Some of the key points from customer reviews include:

Whether you're in the mood for a classic white cake, a decadent cupcake, or a custom-designed masterpiece, Three Brothers Bakery has something for everyone. Visit them today to indulge in some of the best baked goods in town!

House of Pies Restaurant & Bakery, Houston#14
Strengths
  • The chicken Parmesan and strawberry rhubarb pie were exceptional, creating a blissful dining experience.

  • The food is delicious, and the service provided by the staff, especially Sam, is attentive and polite.

  • The cozy atmosphere, delicious food, and attentive staff make House of Pies a must-visit spot.

  • The extensive selection of pies and cakes, like the Bayou Goo, ensures a delightful experience.

House of Pies Restaurant & Bakery

4.34,250 reviews
11311 Fuqua St, Houston, TX 77089, United States

House of Pies Restaurant & Bakery is a cherished establishment in Houston that offers a delightful experience for all. They provide a wide range of services, including No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in options. The restaurant is known for its fast service and standout offerings like Great coffee, Great dessert, and Great tea selection. Customers rave about the cozy atmosphere and the attentive staff, making it a favorite spot for Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, and even Solo dining.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

The main points in one table

#BusinessRatingReviews
#12 Phat Bastard Pies 4.963
#2Lucy Pearls 4.7169
#3Proud Pie 4.61,372
#4Flying Saucer Pie Company 4.61,346
#5Pie Factory 4.828
#6Texas Pie Guy 4.818
#7Ms. Myrtle's Bakery Shoppe 4.3171
#8Three Brothers Bakery 4.2513
#9Flo Paris 4.2364
#10House of Pies 4.45,903
#11House of Pies 4.45,215
#12Epicure Café 4.4426
#13Three Brothers Bakery 4.1419
#14House of Pies Restaurant & Bakery 4.34,250
#15Dessert Gallery Bakery & Cafe 4.31,889

Do you manage a business?

Manage my listing

Map of Key Lime Pies in Houston

Immerse in the tantalizing, tart world of Houston's key lime pie offerings. From the inviting uptown bakeries to the bustling downtown cafés, our city is brimming with variations of this classic dessert. We've compiled a comprehensive guide of the must-visit spots for this citrus treat. Behold, your map to the best key lime pie places in Houston. Engage your taste buds and start exploring!

Finding good Key Lime Pies in Houston

  1. Explore dessert menus featuring the iconic key lime pie.
  2. Compare establishments based on customer reviews and ratings.
  3. Discover key lime pies in a wide price range, satisfying both luxury seekers and bargain hunters.
  4. Identify locations near you and their operating hours.

Questions people often ask

What is key lime pie?

Key lime pie is a popular dessert that originated in the Florida Keys. It is made with a graham cracker crust, a filling consisting of key lime juice, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk, and topped with whipped cream or meringue. The pie is known for its tangy and refreshing flavor, which comes from the use of Key limes rather than regular limes. It is a beloved dessert that is enjoyed by many for its unique taste. If you are looking for a delicious and refreshing dessert to enjoy, key lime pie is a great choice that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Where can you find the best key lime pie in Houston?

If you are in Houston and craving a delicious key lime pie, there are several places where you can find the best versions of this dessert. Some popular options include The Flying Saucer Pie Company, H-E-B, and Goode Company Seafood. These establishments are known for their high-quality ingredients, tasty crusts, and authentic key lime flavor. Be sure to check them out if you want to indulge in a slice (or two) of key lime pie in Houston. Whether you prefer a classic version of the pie or a unique twist, these spots have something for everyone who loves this tangy and sweet dessert.

Is key lime pie gluten-free?

Yes, key lime pie can be made gluten-free with a few modifications to the traditional recipe. To ensure that the dessert is safe to eat for those with gluten intolerance or celiac disease, simply use a gluten-free graham cracker crust or make a crust from almonds or gluten-free oats. The filling of the pie is naturally gluten-free as it consists of key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and egg yolks. By making a few simple substitutions, you can enjoy a delicious gluten-free key lime pie without sacrificing flavor or texture. Many bakeries and restaurants offer gluten-free options for their key lime pie, so be sure to inquire about ingredients if you have dietary restrictions.

Can you make key lime pie without key limes?

While key limes are traditionally used to make key lime pie, you can also make a version of the dessert using regular limes. The flavor profile will be slightly different, as key limes are more tangy and aromatic than regular limes. If you are unable to find key limes at your local grocery store, you can still enjoy a delicious lime pie by using regular limes. The key to capturing the essence of a traditional key lime pie lies in the balance of sweet and tangy flavors, which can still be achieved with regular limes. Experiment with different types of limes to find the flavor profile that suits your taste preferences, and enjoy a tasty lime pie that satisfies your dessert cravings.

Related rankings